Extradition in New Jersey Criminal Cases: A Comprehensive Guide by Brett M. Rosen, Esq.

Extradition & New Jersey Criminal Cases

Extradition in New Jersey Criminal Cases

Extradition in New Jersey Criminal Cases

Facing criminal charges is stressful enough, but what happens when those charges originate in another state? This is where extradition comes into play. Extradition is the legal process by which one state (or country) surrenders an individual to another state to face pending criminal charges. This in-depth guide will explore the intricacies of extradition in New Jersey, providing crucial information for anyone facing this complex legal situation.

Understanding Extradition: The Basics

The foundation of extradition lies in Article IV, Section 2, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution, known as the Extradition Clause. This clause mandates that a state must deliver a person charged with a crime in another state to that state upon demand. This ensures that individuals cannot evade justice by fleeing across state lines.

Key Terms in Extradition:

  • Demanding State: The state where the alleged crime occurred and which is seeking the individual’s return.
  • Asylum State: The state where the individual is currently located.
  • Fugitive from Justice: An individual who flees one state to avoid prosecution or punishment for a crime.
  • Governor’s Warrant: A warrant issued by the Governor of the demanding state authorizing the arrest and extradition of the fugitive.

The Extradition Process in New Jersey

New Jersey follows the Uniform Criminal Extradition Act (UCEA), adopted by most states, to govern interstate extradition proceedings. Here’s a breakdown of the typical process:

  1. Criminal Charge and Flight: An individual is charged with a crime in the demanding state and subsequently flees to New Jersey (the asylum state).

  2. Arrest Warrant: The demanding state issues an arrest warrant for the individual.

  3. Request for Extradition: The demanding state’s governor sends a formal request for extradition to the Governor of New Jersey. This request includes supporting documents like the arrest warrant and an affidavit outlining the charges.

  4. Governor’s Warrant Review: The Governor of New Jersey reviews the extradition request and supporting documents to determine if they meet the legal requirements.

  5. Issuance of Governor’s Warrant: If the request is deemed valid, the Governor of New Jersey issues a Governor’s Warrant authorizing the arrest of the individual.

  6. Arrest and Detention: Law enforcement officers in New Jersey arrest the individual based on the Governor’s Warrant. The individual is then brought before a judge and informed of the extradition request.

  7. Extradition Hearing: The individual has the right to an extradition hearing in New Jersey. At this hearing, the court will determine whether:

    • The individual is the person named in the warrant.
    • The individual is charged with a crime in the demanding state.
    • The individual is a fugitive from justice.
  8. Habeas Corpus: The individual may file a writ of habeas corpus to challenge the legality of their detention and the extradition process. This writ asks the court to review whether the individual is being held lawfully.

  9. Extradition to Demanding State: If the court finds the extradition request valid, the individual will be transported to the demanding state to face the charges.

Defenses to Extradition in New Jersey

While extradition is a powerful legal tool, it’s not without its challenges. An individual facing extradition can raise several defenses to fight the process:

  • Identity: The individual can argue they are not the person named in the warrant.
  • Not a Fugitive: The individual can argue they were not in the demanding state when the crime occurred or that they did not flee to avoid prosecution.
  • Insufficient Documentation: The individual can challenge the validity of the extradition request based on deficiencies in the supporting documents.
  • Violation of Rights: The individual can argue that their constitutional rights were violated during the arrest or extradition process.
  • Motive: The individual can argue that the extradition request is motivated by improper reasons, such as discrimination or retaliation.
  • Humanitarian Concerns: In rare cases, the individual may raise humanitarian concerns, such as serious health issues or fear of persecution in the demanding state.

Waiver of Extradition

An individual can choose to waive extradition, voluntarily agreeing to return to the demanding state. This can expedite the process and potentially be viewed favorably by the court in the demanding state. However, it’s crucial to consult with an attorney before waiving extradition to understand the implications and ensure it’s in the individual’s best interest.

The Role of an Attorney in Extradition Cases

Navigating the complexities of extradition requires experienced legal counsel. An attorney can play a crucial role in:

  • Challenging the Extradition Request: An attorney can investigate the case, review the supporting documents, and raise any legal defenses to fight the extradition.
  • Protecting Your Rights: An attorney can ensure your constitutional rights are protected throughout the process and that you are treated fairly.
  • Negotiating with Authorities: An attorney can negotiate with authorities in both states to potentially resolve the case or arrange for a voluntary surrender.
  • Representing You in Court: An attorney can represent you at the extradition hearing and any subsequent court proceedings.

FAQs about Extradition in New Jersey

  1. Can I be extradited for a misdemeanor offense?

Yes, extradition can be sought for both felony and misdemeanor offenses, although it’s more common for serious crimes.

  1. How long can I be held in custody during the extradition process?

The UCEA allows for a reasonable time to complete the extradition process. However, if delays occur, you can petition the court for release on bail.

  1. Can I fight extradition if I believe I’m innocent of the charges?

The extradition hearing is not meant to determine guilt or innocence. The focus is on whether the legal requirements for extradition are met. You can still fight extradition based on legal technicalities or procedural errors.

  1. What happens if I waive extradition?

If you waive extradition, you will be transported to the demanding state to face the charges. You will still have the right to an attorney and to defend yourself in court.

  1. Can I be extradited from New Jersey to a foreign country?

International extradition involves different procedures and treaties. It’s a more complex process and typically requires involvement from the federal government.

FAQs Continued

  • Can I fight extradition even if I am guilty of the charges?

Yes, you can still challenge extradition even if you believe you are guilty. The extradition hearing focuses on the legality of the process, not on determining your guilt or innocence.

  • Do I need an attorney for an extradition hearing?

Yes, it is highly recommended to have an experienced criminal defense attorney represent you at an extradition hearing. An attorney can protect your rights, raise legal defenses, and negotiate with authorities on your behalf.

  • How long does another State have to pick up a defendant for extradition in New Jersey before being released?

While not a strict rule, many states, including New Jersey, operate with an informal 30-day guideline. If the demanding state fails to pick up the individual within approximately 30 days, the individual may be eligible for release.

  • Can the 30 days be extended?

New Jersey law (N.J.S.A. 2A:160-25) allows a judge to extend this period for up to an additional 60 days if necessary. This extension is usually granted if the demanding state can demonstrate good cause for the delay.

Why Choose Brett M. Rosen, Esq. for Your Extradition Case?

Top-Shelf Criminal Defense Attorney in New Jersey

He’s a highly respected criminal defense attorney based in Elizabeth, New Jersey, and yes, he absolutely can help with an extradition case in New Jersey.

Here’s why he’s the right choice for someone facing extradition:

  • Deep Understanding of Extradition Law: Brett M. Rosen has a strong command of both federal and New Jersey extradition laws. He knows the intricacies of the Uniform Criminal Extradition Act (UCEA), the Interstate Agreement on Detainers (IAD), and the legal strategies that can be used to challenge extradition requests.
  • Experienced Trial Lawyer: He’s a Certified by the Supreme Court of New Jersey as a Criminal Trial Attorney, a distinction held by a very small percentage of attorneys in the state. This means he has extensive courtroom experience and is a skilled advocate for his clients.
  • Track Record of Success: He has a proven history of successfully defending clients against a wide range of criminal charges, including those that often lead to extradition requests, such as drug offenses, assault, and theft.
  • Aggressive Representation: He’s known for his passionate and aggressive approach to defending his clients. He will fight tirelessly to protect your rights and explore every possible avenue to challenge extradition or negotiate a favorable outcome.
  • Client-Focused Approach: He prioritizes his clients’ needs and well-being, offering 24/7 availability and personalized attention to ensure they feel supported and informed throughout the extradition process.

How Brett M. Rosen Can Help in an Extradition Case:

  • Analyze the Extradition Request: He will meticulously review the extradition documents to identify any deficiencies or procedural errors that could be grounds for challenging the request.
  • Investigate the Charges: He will thoroughly investigate the underlying criminal charges in the demanding state to assess the strength of the case and identify potential defenses.
  • Challenge the Extradition: He will raise all available legal defenses to fight extradition, including challenges to identity, insufficient documentation, violation of rights, and humanitarian grounds.
  • Negotiate with Authorities: He will engage in negotiations with authorities in both New Jersey and the demanding state to explore possibilities for a more favorable resolution, such as reduced charges or alternative arrangements.
  • Represent You in Court: He will provide skilled and effective representation at the extradition hearing and any subsequent court proceedings.

Facing extradition is a stressful and complex situation. Having an experienced and dedicated attorney like Brett M. Rosen on your side can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case.

If you or someone you know is facing extradition in New Jersey, don’t hesitate to contact Brett M. Rosen, Esq. for a free consultation. He’s ready to discuss your case, answer your questions, and provide the expert legal guidance you need to navigate this challenging process.

908-312-0368 & brett@nynjcriminalcivilesq.com

Disclaimer: This information is provided for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. It is essential to consult with an attorney to discuss your specific legal situation.

In Sep 2019 I was a victim of False acquasition of Domestic voilence by my ex wife. I was arrested and charged with Simple Assault and a temporary restraining order was given against me. I was referred to Mr Brett by another law firm. I met Mr Brett and he gave me too much confidence. We discussed the case and found alot of conflicting statements in her statement which she gave to the police and in the protection order. On the trail day I had no witness but she had two witnesses, her mother and the police officer. When the trail started Mr Brett started her cross examination and with every next question she was becoming pale. It was a very difficult time for her on the witness podium and she was not able to answer alot of questions. Then came her Mother's turn she literaly started shivering when Mr Brett started asking her questions. Protection order trail normally takes few hours but this trail continued for 8 straight hours. Her Attorney was clueless, the police officer in the court room was astonished that whats going on. On the trail day of the Simple Assault criminal case, Mr Brett prepared the case very well and had a long session with me also 2 days before the trail. We had an expert witness as an Immigration Attorney, my sister came to US to testify. Seeing all that she got scared and ended up dismissing the case. Mr Brett got me away from the most difficult time of my life.
Ahmad